Friday, October 5, 2012

Father Son Fishing Trip by Chad Foster

"This past weekend I took our nine year old son, Graham, out to the flats in Mexico Beach, FL for his first-ever Redfish adventure. While I stood in the back of the Frontier and paddled, Graham stood up in the front of the boat looking for Reds. Only because we could both stand at the same time were we able to locate, stalk, and cast to a school of huge Reds. Graham hooked and landed not one but two 24" Reds on his first trip out!  Bottom line...But for the Frontier we would not have the special memories we now have from that amazing day on the flats."
Chad Foster - Host
ESPN's Fly Fishing America

NuCanoe Frontier 12 Review By D.H. Cushman

Part 1

As I paddled the old kayak through the secluded marsh near St. Simons Island, Georgia, I thought “there has to be a better mousetrap.”  It wasn’t because I was unhappy with my Wilderness Systems Ride 135.  The old yak had served me well, and at the time, it fit the bill for what I was looking for – a stable kayak to access fishing spots.  Just ask my patient, albeit eye rolling wife, about the ordeal leading up to purchasing my first Sit on Top (SOT) kayak in 2008.  Needless to say, I did tons of research and thought I was purchasing the perfect kayak.  What I came to realize is there isn’t a perfect kayak, but there are some that come pretty close.  For almost everyone, there are features that are more important (than others) and can change based on what your needs are.  So began the endless hours of searching for the perfect boat so I could join my fly fishing buds in pursuit of our quarry.  The Ride 135 was a quality boat, but it was pretty evident – I needed a change.

Perhaps I should start at the beginning.  I am a fly fisherman first and a kayaker second.  I have nothing against the casual or hardcore kayaker and canoeist.  I enjoy getting out on the water as much as anyone, but generally my purpose to be on the water is for reasons of the fly…

So my quest began.  To find a kayak, canoe or boat that would fit the following criteria:  stable enough to fly fish from; light enough to easily transport; versatile enough to allow one or two people (and maybe a dog) to comfortably use; durable enough to withstand use (ie. abuse); high quality design and craftsmanship; and simple design.  Alas, I again need to mention the most important feature I was searching for – the craft had to be crazy stable.  Not just a semi-secure platform from which to occasionally stand while only in calm, current free water, but stable enough to stand while thrashing about with a fly rod, poling, paddling or just stretching in moving and/or rough water conditions. 

The Search Begins

Pouring through the information highway (or maybe over it), I remembered NuCanoe (  I had seen their earlier version (NuCanoe 10 and NuCanoe 12) at a NuCanoe Dealership while on a kayak trip to Cambridge, Maryland in July 2011.  It was truly happenstance when my two fly fishing buddies and I pulled into the shop for some local fishing knowledge and there was a yak that looked like no other.  I was intrigued at the design and the salesman who emerged from the store quipped that the main draw was the craft’s stability.  Upon talking with him further, he let it slip there would be a new model coming out soon and this one was rumored to be even more stable and tout scupper holes.
I thought back on this encounter while scouring specs on the vast assortment of kayak models out there, including the Jackson Coosa, Hobie Mirage Pro Angler, KC Kayaks K12, Diablo, etc.  There were so many manufacturers and models to consider.  I took a step back and had to prioritize what I was looking for, so it came down to the main consideration – the ability to stand and fish.  Not stand and wobble, mind you, but stand while in wind, waves or current and cast (or thrash in my case) a fly rod.  Of course there were many other criteria to consider as well, including portability, weight, design and of course core qualities I demand in any equipment I rely on which include manufacturer’s reputation, warranty and their customer service.

As I searched and surfed for NuCanoe, I pleasantly discovered the Maryland salesman was correct.  NuCanoe was just starting to introduce their newest model – the Frontier 12.  I started researching the craft and found it not only would meet the stability criteria, but from the videos I watched it blew all kayak and canoe competitors away in the stability department. 

I also discovered the second box on my criteria was approaching a check mark too.  Portability wise, NuCanoe designed the ultimate personal transport system.  My research revealed the intentional hole in the transom of the craft – don’t worry it sits well above the waterline - served several purposes.  Most importantly, it was the quick install for their proprietary transport cart that allowed for traditional wheeling of the craft.  In addition, when one wanted to load the yak on the top of their vehicle – mine being a Toyota 4-Runner – the solo paddler could do it by themself.  Thanks to watching another video, all it took was to attach the cart, rotate the vessel 180 degrees to an upside down position, and rest the Frontier’s bow on the rear roof area or luggage rack.  The solo “loader” picked up the stern of the Frontier and slid the yak into place for tie down and transport.  What a great, and best of all, a simple design.  No more dead lifting a kayak by yourself up onto the roof of your vehicle.

I continued my research of the Frontier 12 and devoured as much information as I could find.  NuCanoe and You Tube offer many videos that will help educate any prospective user and/or buyer. 

I had another lucky break when I happened to find information on Tar River Paddle Sports (  They are a NuCanoe Dealer in Rocky Mount, North Carolina.  Frank Bandy is the owner/operator, and as luck would have it he was going to be near Richmond, Virginia, participating in a boat show premiering the Frontier 12.  I arranged a meeting with Frank and got my first look at this new design.  First off, Frank is an absolute gentleman and I appreciate the willingness he showed to educate me on the Frontier 12. 

First Impressions

The boat looked fantastic and it appeared just as it had in all the media I had scoured.  The craftsmanship, fit and function were all there.  I want to also point out that this first model was NuCanoe’s preproduction model.  Frank assured me the “new” boat would look even better when it started rolling off the assembly line.

A list of the NuCanoe Frontier 12’s design features include:  Gear vault with dry storage bag, internal rod chamber, universal mount docks, multi-seat bases, cast & blast deck, 70″ freedom track, 360° mobility (with optional swivel seats), cup holders, paddle holder, figure eight cleat, scupper holes, talon pad, crate space and motor mount.  In addition here are the Frontier 12 specs: 
            Length                       12’
            Width                          41“
Deck Width               20”
Weight                       77 lbs
Capacity                    650 lbs
Draft                           3–5“
Max Power                2 HP or equivalent

One important question to ask in regard to the Frontier 12 – is it a kayak or canoe?  We could argue that question all day, but suffice to say it’s both a kayak and canoe and some would call it a hybrid.  Personally, I refer to it as a kayak but we all know about opinions and this article is full of my own – please take them accordingly…

More Research

As a follow up to meeting Frank, I called NuCanoe to get some further details.  By happenstance, I talked with Blake Young.  He is NuCanoe’s Director of Business Development and his demeanor further sold me on the customer service aspect of the company.  I asked lots of questions – likely above and beyond what the average prospective kayak owner might ever think (or care) to ask.  I was on a mission to learn and the Frontier 12 had stoked my learning desire.  Blake was happy to answer my questions and was equally eager to expand on many “what for” curiosities related to the Frontier 12’s design, function, durability and operation.  He also explained “they” were planning on shipping the Frontier 12 to buyers starting March 1st. 

Pulling the Trigger

Long story short and understandably, I needed no more convincing and worked out all necessary details and ordered a NuCanoe Frontier 12 in the hunter brown color – this was probably not a huge surprise.

I decided there would be a few items (i.e. necessities) I would add to the standard Frontier 12.  A transport cart was a definite “have to have” – this was one key feature that sold me on easily transporting the Frontier. 

Two folding swivel seats were in order for flexibility and maneuverability.  These seats with upgraded stainless steel swivels are secured to the included bench seats via a quick release mount.  The base of the swivel slides into the mount and can be taken off (no tools required) to facilitate a streamlined and lighter load for transport.  I have only used one seat for my adventures (up to now at least – my wife doesn’t share the same enthusiasm for fishing as I do) the beauty of the modular type system allows the user to position two seats for additional passengers.  The bench seat “base” secures to the freedom track system by a sliding nut held recessed in the rail.  A knob-ed bolt on each side of the bench attaches to the sliding nut and gives flexibility for custom seat positioning.  

Cannon manufactures 275 cm paddles specifically for NuCanoe to accommodate the wide profile of the Frontier 12.  I chose the lighter Cannon Wave Carbon paddle though the fiberglass version is only 1 ounce heavier at 35 ounces. 

Despite taking a minimalistic approach to my fly fishing, I also opted for two fly rod holders.  I chose the Ram-Mount version which NuCanoe distributes featuring a YakAttack MightyBolt.  They secure directly to the freedom track (no tools needed) which again adds to your ability to customize according to your style. 

A stand up handle and anchor rope line guide kit rounded out the purchases.  The standup handle connects via rope and carabineer near the front handle and provides something to grab and pull you into a standing position.  I didn’t really need this item and luckily it was inexpensive.  As I will report later, standing in the Frontier is a snap and I find his item would only add as something to snag a fly line.  The anchor rope line kit is a ¼” reflective line for the anchor but includes a rubber plug w/bushing intended to fit inside the hole in the transom and prevent the anchor rope from rubbing the boat.  The line is fine and I like the reflective strip weaved into the line.  However, more on the rubber plug w/bushing later, but let’s suffice it to say there is room for improvement on this small item.

My Boat

Finally, the wait is over.  I receive a phone call from the shipping company and I go pick the new yak up.  The securing and transport via my Toyota 4-Runner’s OEM roof rack is perfect.  I used a strap for each crossbar as I did for the old kayak and the Frontier 12 rides up there like it was made for it.  No pun intended about the “ride” but it’s important to note, I sold my Ride 135 as a prerequisite for my new purchase.  She was a good yak but it was time to upgrade.

As I described earlier, the transport cart made solo loading and unloading of the Frontier 12 a breeze.  I would recommend watching the NuCanoe video which provides great instruction, guidance and tips to employ.  After three times loading and unloading, this procedure becomes second nature.  I suggest using a towel or carpet remnant at the rear roof area just behind the roof rack to help prevent the possibility of scratches.  The NuCanoe video also shows side loading as an option if you so desire.

On the Water

My maiden voyage with the Frontier entailed a local lake.  There was no pomp and circumstance and I did not christen the vessel with champagne but more importantly I was indeed impressed.  Crazy stable are the first words that came to mind.  The lake conditions weren’t too harsh but this trip was a good start to become acquainted with this new craft.  No problem standing, walking from the seat to the bow and maneuvering around the boat.  I even caught a few fish by the fly.  My subsequent trip was to another lake in the Northern Virginia Area.  This one required a long haul of the Frontier behind a gate that prevented vehicle traffic – kayaks and canoes welcome but hauling came at your own power.  The transport cart made this a breeze.  Again, I was impressed with the Frontier’s stability.  I was on the water for three hours and paddled the Frontier a long distance.  Tracking was great and the moderate wind did not have an adverse effect.  Now, I was really hankering to get the Frontier out to where I had intended it to be – the river. 

My first river trip was to the South Fork of the Shenandoah River.  This adventure turned out to be a five hour trip and I introduced other variables and elements to test the Frontier’s ability.  Once again the yak triumphed and left me even more satisfied.  I use an anchor “system” which consisted of a 5 lb dive weight secured to the anchor rope.  I rig the rope to pass through the hole in the transom, feed through the anchor guides on the starboard side and secure to the figure eight cleat.  With this configuration, I can drop and pull the anchor much in the same way a drift boat utilizes its anchor system.  Many fellow kayakers realize a kayak shouldn’t be anchored sideways to the current because the risk of capsizing increases exponentially.  By anchoring the vessel from either the bow, or in this case the stern, the craft stays stable in a moderate current.  However, every kayaker needs to know their limitations and avoid getting into a dangerous situation by anchoring in a current too fast for conditions or not up to their ability.  This anchoring method opened up a whole new world of smallmouth bass fishing for me.  I was able to fly fish in a slow to moderate current while at anchor and more impressively while standing.  Yes, let me repeat, I can stand in the Frontier 12 while at anchor (and yes while drifting too) while casting a fly rod.  By fishing this method I can cover all the parts of the river at my pace – anchor, fish a section, pull the anchor drift down to another part and fish that area, repeat, repeat, repeat.  In my old kayak, I had to fish an area while drifting through, paddle back up, fish the same area while drifting, paddle back up – you get the idea. 

Now, wait a minute.  Remember the rubber plug w/bushing intended to secure inside the transom hole and prevent the anchor rope from rubbing the boat?  This is the one item that did not work as intended.  The rubber plug was too short and wide, preventing it from fitting inside the hole in the transom.  I attempted to trim the plug but even when slimmed down it was inadequate to prevent damage to the transom.  However, I employed a solution to correct the “issue”.  I obtained a ¾” outside diameter threaded PVC tubing and cut it slightly longer than the transom thickness.  I screwed a plastic nut on each end (to preventing the ¾” PVC from falling out) and ran the anchor line through the tube.  The tube helps the rope slide through (whether releasing the anchor or pulling it up) and prevents any damage to the boat. I plan on addressing this small issue with Blake at NuCanoe and think it would be worthwhile to offer an anchor tube as a standard item for all Frontiers.  The “tube” must be removed to utilize the transport cart that plugs into the hole in the transom – that’s one reason I only hand tighten the plastic nuts.

Other Design Features

The gear vault is a standard option which includes a hatch in the front providing access to the hull.  This inside hull area serves as the internal rod chamber and will accommodate additional gear.  A dry storage bag (also included) fits on the rim of the gear vault and the hatch “seals” the area from water intrusion.  I’ve had no issues with water seeping into this area.  However, I expect running rapids with standing waves (river) or large waves (ocean or bay) crashing over the front could potentially allow a small amount of water to find its way in.  I have stored a gear bag inside the hull and placed smaller items inside the dry bag as well.  This storage area will not accommodate tall bulky items.  Streamlined items will fit with no issue.  In a perfect world, I would like my backpack to fit in the vault without having to flatten out its contents.  I expect this design cannot be changed – making the storage area larger would alter the design (and ability) of the Frontier.  Personally, I do not care for too many hatches and storage ports in a kayak.  I am definitely “less is more” when it comes to this issue - I feel too many “holes” add just another area for water to find its way in.

The Frontier has seen quite a bit of action – I have spent over 24 combined hours in the craft putting it through its paces.  It has seen use on the Shenandoah River which we talked about earlier, but since then the James River and Potomac River also served as test platforms.  My fly fishing buddies have commented from the seated position of their respective kayaks that I sure am able to stand and fish easily.  Other river users have inquired about the Frontier too – often starting out the conversation by saying they haven’t seen “anything like it” but that’s a good thing…

The versatility of the Frontier has allowed me to fish and “cover” the water habitat I’ve only been able to previously enjoy from a drift boat.  In the near future, I hope to get the Frontier out in the Chesapeake Bay or other saltwater arenas.  I expect it will handle the salt conditions with the same results – unimpeded and in stride.

Other Tidbits

I wanted to take an opportunity to recognize and thank Luther Cifers of YakAttack ( for his help.  I initially spoke with Luther via phone back in March and he provided excellent information and ideas regarding “outfitting” my soon to arrive NuCanoe Frontier 12.  His expertise and patience were extremely helpful in deciding what I needed to properly outfit my new yak.  Luther was enthusiastic and came up with several alternative solutions to help me sort through available equipment and innovative mounting options.  After talking through many solutions, I knew the VisiCarbon Pro light (w/Mighty Mount Ready mounting option) and a Mighty Mount were the appropriate choices to get started.  As I noted above, the NuCanoe Frontier 12’s track system accepts the Ram-Mount Fly Rod holder w/Ram Ball.  Additionally, the MightyBolt found on the bottom of the VisiCarbon Pro also fits the freedom track.  Due to the potential for increased lateral force with the VisiCarbon Pro, I decide a hard mount of the Mighty Mount was in order.  I installed the Might Mount in the rear deck of the Frontier 12 in the mount dock location – port side behind the rear seat position.  I utilized one of the new vacuum plates to install this Mighty Mount.  There is no rear access hatch, and by using the rigging bullet “method” to help with installation it was an easy job even with the hard to reach back area.  The Frontier’s front hatch accesses the inside of the hull so the vacuum plate w/rigging bullet is the “go to” method to facilitate this install.

Conversations with both Blake Young and Luther Cifers confirm NuCanoe and YakAttack have an excellent and ongoing working relationship.  The progressive nature of both companies and their products will only help kayakers to better customize their vessels.

Final Thoughts

To sum it up – I couldn’t have picked a better solution for my needs – a well built and put together kayak with the added accessories are not only practical but simple, durable and quite simply, they work. 

I hope to do a follow up article to keep everyone updated on the progress of the NuCanoe Frontier 12 endeavor.  So far the NuCanoe Frontier 12 is not only a winner but it’s a home run.  The Frontier is a stable, well made and durable vessel which is easy to stand and fly fish from.  Sure, there are other kayaks out there that will get the job done but the beauty of the NuCanoe Frontier 12 hinges on getting it done right.

Thanks again to Blake and NuCanoe for their help, support and innovative ideas.

About the Author

David Cushman is one of the newer members of the Royalty Fly Tyer team with Umpqua Feather Merchants.  His newest fly pattern, the “Great Lakes Goby” will debut later in 2012 and is intended to target smallmouth bass in lakes, rivers and streams.